Easy Handcrafted Margarita Recipe - The Scottarita - 2 Dads with Baggage
margaritas with fresh lime slices

Easy Handcrafted Margarita Recipe – The Scottarita

By Patti Werry from Dinner’s Gonna Be a Little Late Tonight! — My husband Scott loves margaritas. Like really loves them. But what he doesn’t like is the heartburn that often accompanies those that are made with sweet and sour mix. Or Rose’s lime juice. To tackle that problem, he began experimenting with other ingredients and perfected this easy handcrafted margarita recipe over 20 years ago.

Man at his home bar smiling at camera as he squeezes a fresh lime into his freshly made margarita
Scott is the mastermind behind the famous Scottarita.

He originally used frozen limeade (remember making juice from frozen concentrate?) But when Simply Limeade came on the scene he switched to that. Simply Limeade and lime juice give it a fresh, light taste that is a favorite among our family and friends. How much of a favorite? When we told a group of friends we were moving many years ago, their biggest concern was, “But who will make the margaritas?”

(Caution: one is plenty!)

Easy Handcrafted Margarita Recipe – The Scottarita

Prospero Tequila is the primary ingredient in a Margarita recipe including triple sec, Grand Marnier, Simply Limeade and fresh lime juice.
These ingredients are the key to one of the best Margaritas on the planet.

Ingredients for Easy Handcrafted Margarita Recipe

Let’s start off by being crystal clear: proper margaritas are never blended. The best margaritas are always served on the rocks. Salt on the rim is a matter of personal taste, and it’s amazing the strong opinions people have about salt or no-salt preferences.

Yield: One Margarita

  • 2 ounces Reposado* Tequila – Cazadores or Don Felix recommended (or Jon likes Prospero Tequila)
  • 1/2 ounce Triple Sec
  • 1/2 ounce Cointreau (Grand Mariner works too)
  • 2 ounces Simply Lime limeade
  • Juice of half a fresh lime – Scott says look for smooth skinned limes

* Reposado tequilas are aged for 2 – 12 months in oak which rounds out and softens the flavor. It’s a perfect tequila for margaritas and other mixed drinks.

Freshly made margarita with man squeezing lime
Fresh lime is an important ingredient in Scott’s margarita recipe.

Directions for Easy Handcrafted Margarita Recipe

Honestly, this margarita could not be easier to make!

  1. Fill a low ball glass with ice (preferably crushed or small cubes).
  2. Add liquor.
  3. Top with limeade.
  4. Stir and serve.
Print Recipe
Easy handcrafted margarita recipe
Always combine the liquors in the glass first before adding the lime juices in this margarita recipe.

Like a Good Cocktail?

If you like this easy handcrafted Margarita recipe, here are a few other cocktail recipes to try out:

Summer Cocktail Recipes to Cool and Refresh

5 Summer Drink Recipes

The pina of a blue agave plant for making tequila in Mexico.
The pina is the center part of a Blue Agave plant that is used to make tequila.

Pin it!

Sign up for Cookbook Recipe Updates!

    Array We can book your trip! Let us help you plan.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *